Lefty, LLC v. Macchiarini CA1/4
Appellant Lefty, LLC (Lefty) appeals from an adverse judgment against it following a bench trial, asserting the trial court erred in enforcing what it contends is an invalid liquidated damages clause. Lefty advances two arguments on appeal: (1) the trial court improperly evaluated the reasonableness of the liquidated damages amount by looking in hindsight to the actual damages suffered, not to the anticipated damages at the time the clause was agreed to, and (2) even if the trial court correctly looked to anticipated damages, it improperly evaluated the reasonableness of liquidated damages by including certain costs that were not eligible for inclusion in its calculation of anticipated damages. We see no merit to either argument and therefore affirm.
Comments on Lefty, LLC v. Macchiarini CA1/4