Joiner v. Sanchez CA2/1
On July 3, 2014, Robert L. Joiner (Robert Sr.), Mary Joiner (Mary), and Robert D. Joiner (Robert Jr.) (collectively, the plaintiffs) filed a complaint alleging breach of contract, fraud and conversion against Al’s Body Shop, Narciso Sanchez (Narciso), Idilio Sanchez (Idilio) and Idelsis Sanchez Gheldof (Idelsis) (collectively, the defendants) over the repair of a Flying Spur Bentley belonging to Robert Jr. and the defendants’ failure to return a S500 Mercedes Benz and a Chevrolet Biscayne belonging to Robert Sr. and Mary. After a two-day bench trial, the trial court found that the defendants were not liable for breach of contract or fraud with respect to any of the vehicles but did find that the defendants had taken actions constituting conversion with respect to the Mercedes and the Chevrolet. While the trial court awarded the plaintiffs no damages for the conversion of the Chevrolet, the court awarded the plaintiffs $211,590.06 for the conversion of the Mercedes.
Comments on Joiner v. Sanchez CA2/1